The Second Chamber of the EU General Court
made clear that the Citizens’ initiative cannot impose anything to the
legislative-elected bodies
by Emanuele Bonini
Direct democracy is not for ever, and is not for everything. Especially
in context of indirect democracy. The latter is based on representative
bodies such as Parliaments, meaning that these bodies keep their
supremacy, their own right to decide. Do the people decide? Yes and not.
They decide who will decide on their behalf. With such rules of the
game, people's Institutions elected by people «are the law» and always
retain discretionary power as regards the action to be taken.
So ruled today
the Second Chamber of the General Court of the European Union, making
clear that European citizens’ initiative (ECI) cannot replace the
law-making power of the European Commission.
ECI is a EU mechanism aimed at increasing direct democracy by allowing
active participation of EU citizens. Citizens’ initiative is nothing but
the possibility of submitting to the European Commission any
appropriate proposal on matters where citizens consider that a legal act
of the Union is required. In order to have a proposal notified, at
least one million eligible signatories coming from at least one quarter
of all Member States are required.